• Stephan Bergmann's avatar
    Remove *_Test product, so cppunittester can be NONE again · 359472b2
    Stephan Bergmann yazdı
    ...as per #libreoffice-dev IRC:
    
    Sep 19 10:32:24 <mst__> sberg, moggi  why the hell is that thing named
      "cppunit/cppunittester" and inside a subdir?  it's obstructing my attempt to
      put it in $(INSTDIR)/program
    Sep 19 10:33:28 <mst__> (... and if you wonder "wtf does it have to do with
      INSTDIR" you have never heard of awesome LibreOffice_Test installset.... not
      that i would know who needs it :)
    Sep 19 10:36:36 <sberg> mst__, it is in a subdir of solver/*/bin so that on
      Windows it would not accidentally have picked DLLs next to itself instead of
      the module-local DLLs it was supposed to test (back when we had module-local
      output trees)
    Sep 19 10:37:02 <mst__> sberg, ahh hysteric reasons then, /me renames it
    Sep 19 10:37:55 <tml> mst__, if nobody you know uses LibreOffice_Test, just kill
      it?
    Sep 19 10:38:59 <sberg> mst__, tml, LibreOffice_Test was conceived by pmladek
      and/or kendy, IIRC
    Sep 19 10:40:31 * kendy does not remember anything about it :-)
    Sep 19 10:42:17 <sberg> wasn't that something so users (or QA people?) could
      easily run the smoketest against an installation, to see whether the
      installation is any good at all, by installing that LibreOffice_Test alongside
      the installation proper?
    Sep 19 10:43:26 <sberg> mst__, ...and I'd unscientifically vote to kill it
    Sep 19 11:34:23 <pmladek> mst__, sberg: I have created the LibreOffice_Test
      package for one QA guy. He does not longer work on LO. I am not sure if anyone
      else started to use it. So, I think that it can be killed.
    
    Oct 17 18:18:07 <tml_> sberg: have you ever noticed that when you try to
      actually run instdir/unxmacxi/LibreOfficeDev.app , the system actually tries
      to run cppunittester inside the app bundle (it says so in the crash report)
      (it crashes because cppunittester requires a specialized DYLIB_LIBRARY_PATH
      apparently)
    Oct 17 18:19:29 <tml_> I suspect that the system when cppunittester as part of
      the build process is run from inside instdir (i.e. inside an app bundle) the
      system "caches" this false knowledge, and thinks that the executable of the
      app bundle is cppunittester...
    Oct 17 18:19:36 <sberg> tml_, no, never noticed; with "run
      instdir/unxmacxi/LibreOfficeDev.app" you mean calling "open
      instdir/unxmacxi/LibreOfficeDev.app"?  (I always call
      .app/Contenst/MacOS/program explicitly)
    Oct 17 18:19:52 <tml_> yes, I mean "open instdir/..."
    Oct 17 18:20:53 <tml_> some googling tells me that at least years ago, the
      CFBundleExecutable key in the Info.plist is ignored if it is manually changed,
      so I guess similar caching of mapping between an app bundle and which
      executable to actually run happens in this case
    Oct 17 18:23:17 <tml_> and last year somebody even claims "And while on Mountain
      Lion, CFBundleExecutable seems to be a no-op", which would be odd, surely
      there must be widely used apps that have several executables inside the MacOS
      directory; how would the system know which one to run when the app is run?
    Oct 17 18:24:38 <tml_> hmm, apparently the code that handles this might be open
      source even, http://www.opensource.apple.com/source/CF/CF-744.18/CFBundle.c
    Oct 17 18:25:52 <tml_> some mention of "caches" there yes, my guesses might be
      right
    Oct 17 18:27:05 <tml_> if I cp -R instdir/unxmacxi/LibreOffice.app foo.app and
      open foo.app, it works fine
    Oct 17 18:28:33 <tml_> anyway, I guess it would be cleaner to have cppunittester
      somewhere else even without this problem
    Oct 17 18:37:09 <sberg> tml_, yes, IIRC having cppunittester in instdir was a
      misguided mst decision, because that odd LibreOffice_Test product (that
      pmladek said nobody needs any longer anyway) includes it; I think consensus
      was to kill LibreOffice_Test and move cppunittester where all the other NONE
      executables are, but looks like nobody executed
    Oct 17 18:37:55 <tml_> ah ok, so mst should know what needs to be done? good, no
      need for me to try to hack this now then
    Oct 17 18:38:19 <sberg> tml_, I'll do the cleanup tomorrow, unless somebody
      beats me
    
    This removes smoketest/losmoketest et al along with the *_Test product, as they
    seem to not make sense without it anyway.  smoketest/Executable_libtest.mk
    appears to be a test that could also be run during the build, and only ended up
    in the *_Test product by accident, so I left it untouched for now.
    
    Change-Id: I8024472c909fe0a885eb08ef4d3777f8a9e1f7c8
    359472b2
Module_scp2.mk 1.58 KB